Mano A Mano: Lenovo ThinkPad X300 vs MacBook Air
Sunday, March 9th, 20082008 is going to be a great year for technology. With only three months big announcements have been made, especially in the notebooks area. Many PC vendors have made great announcements and the processor chip makers are going to make news soon.
Recently Lenovo launched their new ultraportable notebook and has declared the war to Apple against their MacBook Air. I made some reviews on the Apple MacBook Air on a post couple of days ago. I know that the announce of the Lenovo ThinkPad X300 was also made a couple of days before, but I wanted to study both notebooks very well before making a comparison… a true “Mano A Mano”.
For this Mano A Mano, I’m going to compare both technologies, design and a couple of more things. Kodachi (the Lenovo’s ThinkPad X300 codename) promises to be a great product, the same as the MacBook Air, both focuses mainly to users that are frequent travelers to need processing power and portability.


|
ThinkPad X300 |
MacBook Air |
Advantage |
|
| Mobility | 92cu”(1.5L) .73 - .92″ (18.6 - 23.4mm) thin 2.93 lbs. (1.33kg) w/3 battery, 4.3 hours 3.12 lbs. (1.42kg) w/ 6 battery, 6.5 hours 3.51 lbs. (1.59kg) w/ 6 and 3 battery, 10 hours |
53cu” (0.87L) 0.16-.76“ thick (4 – 19.3 mm) 3.0 lbs. (1.36kg) Battery Life – 5 hours Battery is not user replaceable |
ThinkPad – lighter, max battery life, choice of batteries Apple – thinner at the thickest point |
| Core Technology | Intel Core 2 Duo SL7100 LV 64 bit 800MHz (965GMS) to 4GB 667MHz DDR2 memory 13.3″ WXGA+ (300 nit) LED Backlight |
Intel core 2 Duo 1.6GHz or 1.8GHz (965GMS) Max 2GB of 667MHz on Board (Not upgradeable) 13.3″ WXGA (300 nit?) LED Backlight
|
ThinkPad – max memory, higher resolution panel Apple – better CPU performance |
| Graphics & Storage | Intel Integrated GMA X3100 SATA 64GB Solid State Drive (optional FDE available) No Turbo Memory (not needed with SSD) 1 Fixed Bay (7 mm) |
Intel Integrated GMA X3100 SATA 64GB Solid State Drive or 80GB 1.8” 4200rpm No Turbo Memory (not needed with SSD) No optical |
ThinkPad –optical drive, FDE option Apple – HDD option for capacity |
| I/O and Audio | No IR, no PS/2, 3 USB 2.0, no Serial, no Parallel, no S-Video out, no Firewire, 0 PC Card slots, 0 Express Card slots; no media reader, yes mic, yes camera, No HDMI | No IR, no PS/2, 1 USB 2.0, no Serial, no Parallel, opt. S-Video out, DVI, no Firewire, 0 PC Card slots, 0 Express Card slots; no media reader, yes mic, yes camera, No HDMI | ThinkPad – 3 USB, stereo speaker w/higher quality Apple – DVI port |
| Manageability | USB Port Replicator No image compatibility Rescue & Recovery, ImageUltra, Away Manager, other ThinkVantage Technologies |
External USB Options Apple iLife Suite – optimized for consumer, not commercial |
ThinkPad – manageability tools Apple– iLife suite |
| Security | Std. TPM v1.2 chip, Opt. Fingerprint, No Smart Card Reader; no Full Data Encryption HDD, BIOS disable of all ports, password manager | No TPM chip, No Fingerprint, No Smart Card Reader; no Full Data Encryption HDD, no PW manager | ThinkPad – A lot better security features |
| Connectivity/Wireless | Intel 802.11n, USB Modem Opt. GPS, Opt. Wi-Max, Yes UWB, Yes Bluetooth Integrated Wireless WAN option 1GB Ethernet (Intel – Centrino Pro Available) Access Connections software |
802.11n Wi-Fi, USB Modem No GPS, No Wi-Max, No UWB, Yes Bluetooth No Wireless WAN option NO Ethernet (USB option) |
ThinkPad – Everything |
| Ease Of Use | ThinkPad Utilities, UltraNav, 7 row keyboard, wireless on/off switch, ThinkLight, individual battery control, super quiet design, superior thermals | 6 row keyboard with reduced travel, touchpad only, backlight keyboard, Ambient Light sensor, Apple machines run HOT | ThinkPad – 7 row keyboard + TrackPoint, Superior Thermals Apple– backlight keyboard, ALS |
| Quality | Roll Cage: Hybrid CFRP top, Mg bottom, EPEAT GOLD Stainless steel display hinges; 2 display latches; Yes shock mount HDD Yes spill resistant keyboard |
Design!, EPEAT Silver No Shock Mount HDD, Yes Accelerometer No Spill Resistant Keyboard |
ThinkPad – dual latches, stronger hinges, stronger case, EPEAT Gold Apple – design is widely considered better |
As you can see both models have their own advantages and disadvantages. I personally think that both are well constructed and are made for different needs. It is clear that the ThinkPad X300 has more technical and features advantages than the MacBook, but the main problem of the ThinkPad X300 is the price. The MacBook Air is a cheaper than the X300, and this is because the X300 uses a Solid State Drive which today it is more expensive than the traditional disks.
Another advantage that the MacBook Air has is that it uses Mac OS X Leppard, which is less propense to get infected by a virus or a malware, Windows Vista with all its security features can easily get infected without an antivirus.
The choice is yours, I hope that the information post here can help to make a better purcharse.

